The Jackie Robinson Foundation's mission is to address the achievement gap in higher-education while facilitating career development among the America's underserved populations. The Foundation honors Jackie Robinson's legacy of humanitarianism and civic-engagement by providing academic and professional resources such as scholarships and mentorship to their scholars across the country. We were tasked with creating a community site for their scholars that contained three sections: a scholar-to-scholar private discussion forum, an ask-a-mentor discussion forum, and a news and bulletin section. An intensive search of discussion platforms led to a rigorous customization of Discourse. By grouping scholars, mentors, and staff separately and then creating discussion category (and sub-category) permissions accordingly, the experience of each user group is tailored to the three sections.